| All-League First Team |
| EIBL |
| 1960 |
Dan Cilo, OF
Chuck Kaufman, SS |
| 1961 |
Mike Nyquist, 3B |
| 1962 |
Mike Nyquist, 1B |
| 1964 |
Steve Dichter, OF
Dick Horton, C |
| 1965 |
Dick Horton, C |
| 1966 |
Gene Ryzewicz, 2B |
| 1967 |
Mickey Beard, SS
Gene Ryzewicz, 2B
Jim Shaw, P |
| 1968 |
Terry Light, OF
Gene Ryzewicz, 2B |
| 1969 |
Bob Mlakar, 2B
Chuck Seelbach, P |
| 1970 |
Craig Conklin, 3B
Bruce Saylor, OF
Chuck Seelbach, P |
| 1972 |
Frank Mannarino, OF |
| 1974 |
Mark Ditmar, 2B |
| 1975 |
Jim Beattie, P |
| 1976 |
Dave DeMarco, OF |
| 1980 |
Joel Chansky, DH |
| 1983 |
Ray Bascio, SS
Tim Whall, 1B |
| 1984 |
Ray Bascio, SS |
| 1987 |
Tom DeMerit, OF
Mark Johnson, 1B
Mike Remlinger, P |
| 1988 |
Bobby Jones, OF |
| 1989 |
Mark Johnson, UT |
| 1990 |
Cam McKennitt, OF |
| 1991 |
Bob Bennett, P
Tim Carey, C
Clark Khayat, RP |
| 1992 |
David Angeramo, RP |
| Ivy League |
| 1993 |
John Clifford, C
Joe Tosone, OF |
| 1994 |
Greg Gilmer, C
Craig Pawling, UT
Andrew Spencer, OF |
| 1995 |
Jake Isler, 3B |
| 1996 |
Andrew Spencer, OF |
| 1997 |
Eric Anderson, C
Mike Conway, 3B
Dan Godfrey, RP
Brian Nickerson, SS |
| 1998 |
Mike Conway, 3B
Mike Levy, C |
| 1999 |
Mike Conway, 3B
Mike Levy, C
James Little, OF |
| 2000 |
Conor Brooks, P
James Little, OF
Jon Miller, RP
Brian Nickerson, 3B |
| 2001 |
Mike Levy, C
Brian Nickerson, 3B
Scott Shirrell, OF |
| 2002 |
Ed Lucas, 3B
Mike Mileusnic, 1B
Scott Shirrell, OF |
| 2003 |
Ed Lucas, SS
Scott Shirrell, OF |
| 2004 |
Josh Faiola, P
Ed Lucas, SS
Tommy Myette, 3B |
| 2005 |
Will Bashelor, OF |
| 2006 |
Will Bashelor, OF
Josh Faiola, P |
| 2007 |
Nick Santomauro, OF |
| 2008 |
Erik Bell, SS
Mike Pagliarulo, 1B
Nick Santomauro, OF
Damon Wright, OF
Russell Young, P |
| 2009 |
Ray Allen, DH
Nick Santomauro, OF
Joe Sclafani, SS
Jim Wren, OF |
| 2011 |
Kyle Hendricks, P
Joe Sclafani, SS
Ryan Smith, RP
Cole Sulser, P |
| 2012 |
Jake Carlson, OF
Ennis Coble, DH
Joe Sclafani, SS
Dustin Selzer, 1B |
| 2013 |
Ennis Coble, OF
Michael Johnson, P
Jeff Keller, OF
Nick Lombardi, 3B
Matt MacDowell, C
Thomas Olson, RP
Matt Parisi, 2B
Joe Purritano, DH |
| 2014 |
Duncan Robinson, RP
Dustin Selzer, 1B |
| 2015 |
Matt Parisi, SS
Patrick Peterson, RP
Duncan Robinson, P |
| 2016 |
Patrick Peterson, RP
Duncan Robinson, P
Thomas Roulis, SS |
| 2017 |
Beau Sulser, P |
| 2018 |
Dustin Shirley, OF |
| 2019 |
Sean Sullivan, 2B
Steffen Torgersen, 3B |
| 2022 |
Tyler Cox, SS
Kade Kretzschmar, OF
Justin Murray, UT |
|
|
| All-League Second Team |
| EIBL |
| 1960 |
George Woodworth, C |
| 1963 |
Mike Bloom, SS
Dick Horton, C
Mike Nyquist, 1B |
| 1964 |
Scott Creelman, P
Henry Ota, 2B |
| 1965 |
Ted Friel, P |
| 1966 |
Pete Barber, P |
| 1968 |
Bob Thomas, 1B |
| 1969 |
Craig Conklin, 3B
Bruce Saylor, OF |
| 1970 |
Tom Hanna, OF |
| 1971 |
Pete Broberg, P |
| 1973 |
Mark Ditmar, SS |
| 1977 |
Dave DeMarco, P |
| 1978 |
Gary Masse, SS |
| 1979 |
Gary Masse, SS |
| 1983 |
Mike Timmons, DH/U |
| 1984 |
Steve Karol, OF
Mike Timmons, DH/U |
| 1985 |
Jim Lavery, 1B |
| 1987 |
Chris Bunker, OF
Mark Mitchell, OF
Todd Twachtmann, 3B |
| 1988 |
John Hommeyer, DH
Mark Johnson, 1B |
| 1989 |
Mark Johnson, P |
| 1990 |
Bob Bennett, P
Brendan Mahoney, OF |
| 1991 |
Cam McKennitt, OF |
| 1992 |
Bob Bennett, P
Tim Carey, C
Clark Khayat, RP |
| Ivy League |
| 1994 |
Jake Isler, 3B |
| 1995 |
Mike Armstrong, 2B
Todd Seneker, 1B
Andrew Spencer, OF
Dave Stefanowicz, RP |
| 1996 |
Jake Isler, 3B
Eric Walania, P |
| 1997 |
Andrew Spencer, OF |
| 2000 |
Mike Mileusnic, DH |
| 2001 |
Joe Rockers, DH |
| 2002 |
Tim Grant, P
Nick Peay, RP |
| 2003 |
Jason DaCosta, OF
Brian Zurhellen, C |
| 2004 |
Josh Bailey, 2B
Will Bashelor, OF
Tim Grant, P
Stephen Perry, P |
| 2006 |
Damon Wright, OF |
| 2007 |
Damon Wright, OF |
| 2008 |
Ryan Smith, RP |
| 2009 |
Kyle Hendricks, P
Jeff Onstott, 2B
Mike Pagliarulo, 1B
Ryan Smith, RP |
| 2010 |
Jason Brooks, 1B
Jake Carlson, OF
Joe Sclafani, SS
Cole Sulser, RP |
| 2011 |
Sam Bean, OF
Ennis Coble, UT
Kyle Hunter, P
Jeff Onstott, 2B |
| 2012 |
Thomas Olson, RP |
| 2013 |
Kyle Hunter, P |
| 2014 |
Jeff Keller, OF
Nick Lombardi, 3B
Joe Purritano, DH |
| 2015 |
Mike Concato, P |
| 2016 |
Rob Emery, UT |
| 2017 |
Chris Burkholder, RP
Michael Danielak, P
Kyle Holbrook, OF |
| 2018 |
Jack Foassand, P
Austen Michel, RP |
| 2019 |
Matt Feinstein, OF |
| 2022 |
Connor Bertsch, 3B
Jack Metzger, RP
Justin Murray, SP
Trystan Sarcone, SP |
|
|
| Player of the Year |
| Ivy League |
| 2000 |
Brian Nickerson, 3B |
| 2004 |
Ed Lucas, SS |
| 2009 |
Nick Santomauro, OF |
| 2018 |
Dustin Shirley, OF |
| 2022 |
Kade Kretzschmar, OF |
| Pitcher of the Year |
| EIBL |
| 1987 |
Mike Remlinger, LHP |
| Ivy League |
| 2000 |
Conor Brooks, RHP |
| 2008 |
Russell Young, LHP |
| 2015 |
Duncan Robinson, RHP |
| 2017 |
Beau Sulser, RHP |
| Rookie of the Year |
| Ivy League |
| 1997 |
Brian Nickerson, SS |
| 2000 |
Mike Mileusnic, 1B |
| 2001 |
Scott Shirrell, OF |
| 2004 |
Stephen Perry, RHP |
| 2009 |
Joe Sclafani, SS |
| 2010 |
Chris O'Dowd, C |
| 2013 |
Joe Purritano, DH |
| 2022 |
Tyler Cox, SS |
Blair Bat Award
Highest Average in League Play |
| 1933 |
Charles Snow (.354) |
| 1946 |
Harry Durham (.423) |
| 1994 |
Greg Gilmer (.476) |
| 2004 |
Ed Lucas (.493) |
| 2009 |
Nick Santomauro (.473) |
| 2022 |
Tyler Cox (.464) |
Three-Time
All-League First Team |
| EIBL |
| 1966-68 |
Gene Ryzewicz '68 |
| Ivy League |
| 1997-99 |
Mike Conway '99 |
| 1997, 2000-01 |
Brian Nickerson '01 |
| 2001-03 |
Scott Shirrell '04 |
| 2002-04 |
Ed Lucas '04 |
| 2007-09 |
Nick Santomauro '10 |
| 2009, 2011-12 |
Joe Sclafani '12 |
| 2014-16 |
Duncan Robinson '16 |
| All-League Honorable Mention |
| EIBL |
| 1977 |
Dave DeMarco, 1B |
| 1980 |
Roberto Balaguer, OF
Brent Cole, 2B |
| 1983 |
Roberto Balaguer, OF |
| 1984 |
Jim Lavery, 1B |
| 1986 |
Tom DeMerit, OF
Todd Twachtmann, 3B |
| 1987 |
John Hommeyer, DH |
| 1988 |
Rob Combi, 2B
Chris Hildebrand, P |
| 1989 |
John Ross, 2B |
| 1990 |
Rich Mazzola, OF |
| 1991 |
Brendan Mahoney, OF |
| 1992 |
Tim Carey, C |
| Ivy League |
| 1993 |
Mike Tallman, P |
| 1994 |
Mike Armstrong, SS
Steve Murphy, P
Todd Seneker, 1B
Dave Stefanowicz, RP |
| 1995 |
Greg Gilmer, OF
Travis Horton, DH |
| 1996 |
Greg Gilmer, OF |
| 1997 |
Mike Armstrong, 2B
Aaron Meyer, DH |
| 1998 |
James Little, OF |
| 1999 |
Conor Brooks, P
Aaron Meyer, 1B |
| 2000 |
Mike Levy, C
Aaron Meyer, 1B
John Velosky, P |
| 2001 |
Derek Draper, OF
Jeff Dutremble, RP
Mike Mileusnic, 1B |
| 2002 |
John Velosky, P |
| 2003 |
Mike Mileusnic, 3B |
| 2004 |
Scott Shirrell, OF
Jeff Speights, 1B
Brian Zurhellen, C |
| 2005 |
Josh Bailey, 2B
Jeff Speights, 1B
Brian Zurhellen, C |
| 2006 |
Jeff Wilkerson, P |
| 2007 |
Keyl Zeis, RP |
| 2008 |
Chase Carpenter, P |
| 2009 |
Johnathon Santopadre, 3B |
| 2010 |
Kyle Hendricks, P
Chris O’Dowd, C |
| 2011 |
Jason Brooks, 1B
Chris O’Dowd, C |
| 2012 |
Adam Frank, P
Mitch Horacek, P
Jeff Keller, OF |
| 2013 |
Cole Sulser, P |
| 2014 |
Matt Parisi, SS
Thomas Roulis, 2B
Nick Ruppert, OF |
| 2015 |
Nick Ruppert, OF |
| 2016 |
Michael Ketchmark, 1B
Nick Ruppert, OF
Dustin Shirley, 2B |
| 2017 |
Michael Calamari, DH
Michael Ketchmark, 1B |
| 2018 |
Matt Feinstein, OF
Cole O’Connor, P
Nate Ostmo, SS |
| 2019 |
Max Hunter, RP |
| 2022 |
Nathan Cmeyla, C
Nathan Skinner, SP |
| 2023 |
Jackson Hower, OF
Peter O’Toole, 2B |
| 2024 |
Nathan Cmeyla, C
Tyler Robinson, OF |
|