Completed Event: Men's Ice Hockey versus Arizona State on December 28, 2025 , Win , 4, to, 1
Final

Men's Ice Hockey
vs Arizona State
4
1
| YEAR | CAPTAIN(S) | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL | |
| 1995Â | Ericka M. Lee '95` | Portland, Maine | Portland | |
| Â Jennifer A. Pitts '95 | Pelham, N.H | Pelham | ||
| Â Kimberly A. Worbovs '95 | Fayetteville, N.Y. | Thomas J. Corcoran | ||
| 1996 | Karen Hersey '96 | Dexter, Maine | Dexter Regional | |
| Lauren McQuade '97 | Princeton, N.J. | The Hun School | ||
| 1997 | Lauren McQuade '97 | Princeton, N.J. | The Hun School | |
| Julia Doster '97 | Birmingham, Ala. | Mount Brook | ||
| 1998 | Christina Maybaum '98 | Essex Fells, N.J. | W. Essex Regional | |
| Bess Tortolani '98 | Harrison, N.Y. | Ursuline School | ||
| 1999 | Laura Mills '00 | Columbus, Ohio | Upper Arlington | |
| 2000 | Stacy Sanders '00 | Towaco, N.J. | Morris Catholic | |
| Erica Morgenstein '01 | Portland, Maine | Portland | ||
| 2001 | Jenny Harsey '01 | Aurora, Ohio | Aurora | |
| Erica Morgenstein '01 | Portland, Maine | Portland | ||
| 2002 | Cherie Comeau '02 | Worcester, Mass. | Notre Dame Academy | |
| Sarah Damon '02 | Islip Terrace, N.Y. | East Islip | ||
| Carla Giugliano '04 | Gansevoort, N.Y. | Saratoga Springs | ||
| 2003 | Lisa Caruso '04 | Totowa, N.J. | Â Passaic Valley | |
| Adrienne Draper '04 | Hughesvilles. Md. | LaPlata | ||
| Danica Giugliano '04 | Gansevoort, N.Y. | Saratoga Springs | ||
| Christine Quattrocchi '03 | Â Albany, N.Y. | Guilderland | ||
| 2004 | Lisa Caruso '04 | Totowa, N.J. | Passaic Valley | |
| Adrienne Draper '04 | Hughesville, Md. | LaPlata | ||
| Jodee Thompson '05 | Carmichael, Calif. | El Camino | ||
| 2005 | Jodee Thompson '05 | Carmichael, Calif. | El Camino | |
| Kerry Conway '05 | Leominster, Mass. | Leominster | ||
| Jess Reiten '06 | Santa Ana, Calif. | Foothill | ||
| 2006 | Erika Owen '06 | Newhall, Calif. | Hart | |
| Jess Reiten '06 | Santa Ana, Calif. | Foothill | ||
| Alice Petryk '06 | White Bear Lake, Minn. | St. Paul Academy | ||
| Lacey Neahr '06 | Perris, Calif. | Notre Dame | ||
| 2007 | Kelly Fry '07 | Marietta, Ga. | Harrison | |
| 2008 | Angela Megaw '08 | Bomoseen, Vt. | Fair Haven Union | |
| Sarah Bankoff '08 | Lynnfield, Mass. | Lynnfield | ||
| Ashley Gleason '09 | Costa Mesa, Calif. | Newport Harbor | ||
| 2009 | Ashley Gleason '09 | Costa Mesa, Calif. | Newport Harbor | |
| Christy Autin '10 | Harwood Heights, Ill. | Ridgewood | ||
| 2010 | None | |||
| 2011 | Audrey Kolodziej | Morton Grove, Ill. | Niles West | |
| 2012 | Hillary Hubert '13 | Grant Park, Ill. | Grant Park | |
| Molly Khalil '12 | Seal Beach, Calif. | Los Alamitos | ||
| Megan Everett '12 | Flemington, N.J. | Hunterdon Central Regional | ||
| 2013 | Hillary Hubert '13 | Grant Park, Ill. | Grant Park | |
| 2014 | Kara Curosh '14 | Munster, Ind. | Munster | |
| Kristen Rumley '15 | Katy, Texas | Cinco Ranch | ||
| 2015 | Kristen Rumley '15 | Katy, Texas | Cinco Ranch | |
| 2016 | None | |||
| 2017 | Maddie Damore '17 | Campbell, Calif. | Saint Francis | |
| 2018 | Tiffany Dyson '18 | Canyon Country, Calif. | Canyon | |
| Morgan Martinelli '19 | Morgan Hill, Calif. | Ann Sobrato | ||
| 2019 | Morgan Martinelli '19 | Morgan Hill, Calif. | Ann Sobrato | |
| Taylor Ward '19 | Toms River, N.J. | Toms River North | ||
| 2020 | Leadership Council | |||
| 2021 | Team Leadership | |||
| 2022 | Team Leadership | |||
| 2023 | Team Leadership | |||
| 2024 | Team Leadership | |||
| 2025 | Team Leadership |